Imidef Blog

GPT-5 Thinking Mode Demystified: When to Use It, How It Works, and What Changes

Eyecatch that intuitively represents GPT-5's Thinking mode (horizontal, no text)

From “Quick Answers” to “AI That Truly Thinks”

GPT-5 introduces a major shift: Thinking Mode.
Instead of answering instantly, it adjusts the “depth of reasoning” based on the question—responding quickly to simple prompts, and diving deep when logic and accuracy matter.

OpenAI describes GPT-5 as an integrated system:

  • Fast response model
  • Deep reasoning model (Thinking)
  • A router that decides which to use

1. What Exactly Is Thinking Mode?

  • Fast Model → Handles most everyday queries
  • GPT-5 Thinking → Engages in multi-step reasoning for complex tasks
  • Router → Automatically switches between them

👉 Users can also explicitly select “GPT-5 Thinking” or request deeper reasoning with prompts.

2. When Should You Use Thinking Mode?

  • Tasks with long dependencies → e.g., requirements → design → implementation → testing
  • Ambiguity needs resolution → identifying assumptions and comparing hypotheses
  • Fact-heavy outputs → research, reviews, or accountable documentation
  • Complex code or refactoring → ensuring design consistency and estimating impact

For simple Q&A or summaries, normal mode is enough—the router auto-optimizes for you.

3. How to Prompt for Better Thinking

Explicit Triggers

  • Select GPT-5 Thinking in the model picker
  • Add an instruction like: “Take time to reason carefully, step by step.”
  • Provide assumptions, constraints, and success conditions upfront

Acceptance Conditions

  • Define output criteria (e.g., comprehensiveness, alternative comparisons, sources)
  • Request falsification checks and a final to-do summary
    → Makes the reasoning process reproducible and transparent

4. Ready-to-Use Templates

A) Defining Web App Requirements

“Reason step by step: assumptions, constraints, non-functional needs, alternatives, risks, mitigations, implementation steps, and execution order.”

B) Refactoring a Codebase

“Investigate this repository for circular dependencies, duplicates, naming inconsistencies, and propose a test plan.”

C) Research & Review

“Summarize points of agreement, compare major positions fairly, cite primary sources, and include limitations from a falsifiability perspective.”

5. What Makes It Different From Older Models?

  • Automatic router = balances speed and depth
  • Improved factual accuracy and dependency tracking
  • Stronger code generation/debugging, better tool integration
  • Enhanced multimodal reasoning (e.g., images + logic)

6. Things to Keep in Mind

  • Still prone to hallucinations → verify critical outputs
  • Longer reasoning costs more time/tokens
  • ChatGPT’s integrated model vs API’s standalone versions may behave differently

7. Operation Tips

  • ChatGPT: Select GPT-5 Thinking or specify intention in the prompt
  • API: Choose between gpt-5, mini, or nano depending on workload
  • Workflow:
    1. Start with normal response
    2. Deep-dive important parts with Thinking
    3. Validate using acceptance templates

8. Key Takeaway: Thinking Mode Is “On-Demand”

Thinking Mode isn’t meant to run all the time.
👉 The secret is to use it only when deeper reasoning is truly valuable—balancing speed and accuracy.

Related Posts